Historically, Butcher Corner has been known as ‘Post-Office Corner’ and then ’Draper’s Corner’ . It has continued to be ‘the most congested place for traffic in the town’  with frequent accidents and prosecutions for loitering and obstruction.
‘… … amongst an assemblage of loiterers congregated near that favourite haunt the Butcher-corner … …’ 
‘The corner is the resort of idle and unemployed men and lads, and serious complaints are frequently made of the annoyance to ladies and others … … The bench intimated their determination to put down the nuisance … 
A letter to the editor is printed, by a disconcerted individual complaining about the extent of loitering on street corners. This street-lounging apparently is most prominent on the Sabbath and especially noticeable on Butcher's Corner which is often impassable by the congregation of youths who make personal and lewd comments to passers-by. The letter is concluded with, 'I trust that in future none but those who are anxious to be thought ignorant and vicious, will be found obstructing our pavements , or idling at street corners , particularly on Sundays'. The writer finishes with, 'I am, obediently, yours, W.D.J.'. 
STREET CORNER LOAFING
At the close of the police business at the Town-hall on Saturday Col. Legard said he wished to make some remarks as to the practice of loafers standing about at the Butcher-Corner. Complaint had been made to him about this practice, and he himself noticed the same faces there day after day - some of them men who, he should think, would not do an honest day’s work if they had the chance. He thought if the police were to give some attention to the evil it might be lessened … … Supt. Silversides readily promised acquiescence.
York Herald, 11 June 1894
 York Herald, 28 December 1888
 York Herald, 10 August 1891
 York Herald, 26 July 1845
 York Herald 5 March 1864
 Malton Messenger, 1 July 1854
A Man named Walker, with his son, was driving down Wheelgate, Malton, in a spring cart, when the horse was startled and dashed down to butcher-corner. The horse attempted to turn up Yorkersgate, but too late, and smashed into the large plate-glass window of Messrs. Snow and Son, drapers. The man and boy were both thrown through the window, and were seriously hurt by the glass. The man had his left shoulder dislocated, his arm broken, one hand cut, and also had a nasty cut several inches long across the lower part of the back. The boy was badly cut on the head, and was for a time insensible (Leeds Times 15 Feb 1896)